The Struggle Within Islam
Following up on my recent post, "Muslim Terrorists are Rare... and Stupid," I just read a good article in the September Smithsonian. The "Struggle Within Islam" explores how most Muslims react to the actions of the minority that commit acts of horrible terror.
“Today, Al Qaeda is as significant to the Islamic world as the Ku Klux Klan is to the Americans—not much at all,” Ghada Shahbender, an Egyptian poet and activist, told me recently. “They’re violent, ugly, operate underground and are unacceptable to the majority of Muslims. They exist, but they’re freaks.
“Do I look at the Ku Klux Klan and draw conclusions about America from their behavior? Of course not,” she went on. “The KKK hasn’t been a story for many years for Americans. Al Qaeda is still a story, but it is headed in the same direction as the Klan.”
Recent comments
- Yeah, in the context of
4 weeks 3 days ago - comparison
4 weeks 4 days ago - Interesting comparison but
4 weeks 4 days ago - It's a slippery slope though
4 weeks 4 days ago - markets
4 weeks 6 days ago - interesting article & comments
4 weeks 6 days ago - MMA
7 weeks 4 days ago - Yup
7 weeks 5 days ago - Hmmmm
7 weeks 5 days ago - Pigs is pigs
13 weeks 2 days ago
Recent Tweets
- SportShotChris: @KarlBode I find it helps to discuss astroturf in terms of past cigarette battles. Cancer? ha! Addictive? wha???
- SportShotChris: I'm #reading The Big Short by Michael Lewis http://t.co/KyI2k3jY
- SportShotChris: RT @elforesto: Komen is still a terrible charity. They regularly bully people with bogus copyright claims. Why would you WANT their co ...

Comments
Interesting comparison but
Interesting comparison but not sure it is that simple. My understanding of the klan is that they were only US motivated with their rhetoric and didn't really have reach beyond US borders, although white supremecy clearly isn't limited to the KKK and the US. I see Al Qaeda as very different with an international agenda. Perhaps the comparison will have more validity when Al Qaeda is further marginalized and condemned in countries where it draws most support.
Now if you want some fun(?) comparisons, compare the propaganda of the KKK to that of the modern day evangelical GOP movement. Prohibition, anti-union, prayer focused meetings, religious symbolism for intimidation, harsh stances on immigration, claims that your way of life is under attack......
comparison
I wasn't saying they are equivalent. The larger point is that while many Americans seem to think al Qaeda is somehow representative of Islam, it is far from it. But yeah, you are totally right about KKK being content to make the US a miserable place without giving a rip for the rest of the world.
Yeah, in the context of
Yeah, in the context of general perception- I think an alarmingly high number of americans draw a straight line between Islam and terrorism.
Post new comment